Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout25-A023 189 Center Street WithdrawnTOWN OF YARMOUTH ° 1146 ROUTE 28, SOUTH YARMOUTH, MA 02664A451 Telephone (508) 398-2231 Ext. 1292^-Fax (508) 398-0836 FEB 0 5 2075 OLD KING'S HIGHWAY HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMA ; ,s Highway APPLICATION FOR Historic District CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS Application is hereby made for issuance of a Certificate of Appropriateness under Section 6 of Chapter 470, Acts of 1973 as amended, for proposed work as described below & on plans, drawings, photographs, & other supplemental info accompany.ng this application. PLEASE SUBMIT 4 Copies OF SPEC SHEET($), ELEVATIONS, PHOTOS, & SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION. Check All Categories That Apply: Indicate type of Building: Commercial Residential 1) Exterior Building Construction: New Building Addition i/Alterations ✓ Reroof ✓Garage Shed Solar Panels Other: 2) Exterior Painting: Siding V, Shutters Doors Trim ✓ Other: 3) Signs/Billboards: New Sign Change to Existing Sign 4) Miscellaneous Structures. Fence Wall Flagpole Pool Other: Please type or print legibly: Address of proposed work: �/ Tf 1 v%T f �- , i + ©� Map/Lot #l� Owner(s): &Fu-/ Mca-Mt-L- _ Phone #. All applications must be submitted by owner or accompanied by letter from owner approving submittal of application. Mailingaddress: / �--G �1�' �Q �� Year built. Email: Agent/contractor: Description of Proposed Wor - 64W t&aµ � e c TIN Al bC� 904 ej-si g-fC• Y�s 1We Signed (Owner or agent): Preferred notification method Phone Email Phone # pox PT141 'ed notification method: hone mail J 6 C Is. ,44 q k1of, r- - Date: > Ownedcontractodagent is aware that a permit is required from the Building Department. (Check other departments, also.) > If application is approved, approval is subject to a 10-day appeal period required by the Act > This certificate is good for one year from approval date or upon date of expiration of Building Permit. whichever date shall be later D All new construction will be subject to inspection by OKH. OKH-approved plans MUST be available on -site for framing & final inspections Rcvd Date: S' y Amount CashICK #: Rcvd by: 45 Days: 31- I �� Date Signed: Approved Approved with _Modifications Denied Reason for Denial. Signed: 1 2 5 - A 0 2 3 APPLICATION #: TOWN OF YARMOUTH 1146 ROUTE 28, SOUTH YARMOUTH, MASSACHUSETTS 02664-4451 Telephone (508) 398-2231 Ext. 1292 Fax (508) 398-0836 OLD KING'S HIGHWAY HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMITTEE Application #: 45-DAY TIMEFRAME WAIVER 25-A023 Project Address: � <Cq w 5V&7 Application Received Date 1?15125- 45 Day Decision Deadline: 3L�7193-_ LNE, I W1 V1 ET1 FEB D 5 2075 Old King's Highway Caric District I/We, the undersigned owner, contractor, or agent, do hereby waive the 45-day timeframe for a determination on our application for a Certificate of Appropriateness/Demolition/Exemption by the Old King's Highway Historic District Committee for the following project: goice , s 1 �S� {,n m V 4Wj kcNS 4 Date: �2 - 0 ZO Z ig ned: Owner Owner Contractor/Agent 25-A023 ����. TOWN OF YARMOUTH ova. OLD KING'S HIGHWAY HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMITTEE ABUTTERS' LIST Applicant's (Owner) Name: Lc-jii4 ryu,6 Vi„I~ l Property Address/Location: evorev S Hearing Date: ]H�.Z✓� Notices must be sent to the applicant and abutters (including owners of land on any public or private street or way) whose property directly abuts or is across the street from the applicant. The OKH Office will send out notices using the addresses as they appear on the most recent applicable tax list. Note. Instructions for obtaining the abutters Map and Lot numbers can be found on the Old King's Highway Department page on the Town website: www.yarmouth.ma.us Map Number Lot Number Applicant Information: Abutter Information: FEB 0 5 1025 Old King's Highway Historic District l LJ d 3y 1 La-1 (o -7 K0 L4a O&Y q0 33.1 . �7 HQ 5:� yi I` 0 5-3 1070 3 Application #: 125-Ap 1401 33.11 1 1 LETTERA MICHAEL J LETTERA LESLIE C 2001 E 2ND AVE UNIT 10C TAMPA, FL 33605 1401 341 1 1 HILLIARD HUGH C PO BOX 113 YARMOUTH PORT, MA 0267"113 1401 35► 1 1 CONNOLLY JAMES B CONNOLLY CAROLE A 195 CENTER ST YARMOUTH PORT, MA 02675 140► 40/ ► 1 TOWN OF YARMOUTH 1146 ROUTE 28 SOUTH YARMOUTH, MA 02664-4463 1401 531 ! 1 NOYES ROBERT F NOYES SHIRLEY M 610 FOX ST LONGBOAT KEY, FL 34228 1401 521 1 1 LET'S LIVE SUMMER LLC C/O KOVAC ELISABETH VIA MELZI D ERIL 36 MILAN, 20154 Please use this signature to certify this list of properties directly abutting and across the street from the parcel located at: 189 Center St., Yarmouth Port, MA 02675 Assessors Mpp 140, Lot 34 Andy Machgdo, Director of Assessing February 10, 2025 FEB 1 i 1015 Old King's Highway Historic District z p q 35' �M,'�\ g7 -A Oa 3 �e � � H tp .a• N �-i gN n Ui Ln r 133ais IdRNT) rn rti W W r•7 V Ln W Ln ri 'r' A o 0 �• u � o � U n :c n Mc. fS° N C1 �y i w a�R to N `ys 4• +z� �D FEB 0 5 2025 Old King's Highway Historic District 111 iV C7 N cu a w � N s c 25-A023 t GENERAL SPECIFICATION SHEET Project Address: FOUNDATION: Material: Exposure (Not to exceed 18"): CHIMNEY: Material) oux olor:WA UTTERS: Material/Color:✓tea Wy� ROOF: Material: S ►�i�+Pi�711 min) fi h Height to Ridge: Color: SIDING: Material/Style: Front:: X. Sides/Rear: -x . COLOR CHIPS Color: Front: �/RX Sides/Rear'. F.4. TRIM: All windows & oors to be trimmed with: e.) &—,K1-,n Material: 6e Color: W 4 DOORS: Qty: �Material: W 0At Color: b1i'N a eg N i�fokA L+ s Style/Size (if not listed/shown on elevations): cKi3 ca x. ��� STORM DOORS: Qty: Material: Color: Rat, GARAGE DOORS: Qty: Mat'I. Style: Color: WINDOWS: !side: Front.' Le ft: "� ight: Rear Color: Manufacturer/Series: QE`�A LI r �C�` l It Matenar Grilles (Required): Pattern (6/6, 2/1, etc ) Grille Type: True Divided Lite: Snap -In: BetweCln Glass: Permanently Applied: Exterior Interior STORM WINDOWS: Qty: Material, SHUTTERS: MatT Style: Paneled Louvered SKYLIGHTS: Qty: Fixed Vented Size DECK: Size: ecking MatT Railing MatT IdAllile Vill Style: N+ 9# rk WALLS/FENCES* (Max 6' height): Height: MatT Style: Color: (Show running footage & location on plot plan.) UTILITY METERS/HVAC UNITS: Location: LIGHTS: Qty: Style: Location(s): LIGHT POSTS: Qty: Material: Location(s): Additional information: Color: Color: Color: Color: ®62 WJV* Color: 14/11, VV �d(� *Finished side of fence must face out from fenced in area. 1299DR5Screening: Color: Color: FEB Q 5 2025 Old King's Highway Historic District 2-General 2 5- A 0 2 3 APPLICATION #: ;l crll� Ed Stafford Lewis Bay Management 1/17/2025 114 Photos • Lewis'We ®r Management LLC 189 Center Street Historic FEB 0 5 2925 Old King's Highway Historic District 2 5 - A 0 2 3 t6 McGuill Residence - 189 Center Street Historic 189 Center Street Historic Decking Replacement Decking to be replaced with boardwalk landmark collection, repla Decking Replacement FEB 0 5 2025 Old King's Highway Historic District 2 5 - A 0 2 3 McGuill Residence 189 Center Street Historic 3 ec_" t J) LANDMAN! COLL E60N BOARDWALK 4 Decking Specification Boardwalk Landmark Collection. FEB D 5 2025 Old King's Highway Historic District Project: McGuill Residence Date: 1/17/2025, 721om Creator. Ed Stafford Decking Specification Boardwalk Landmark Collection. Project: McGuill Residence Date: 1/17/2025, 7:21am Creator: Ed Stafford 2 5 - A 0 2 3 Decking Replacement 4 f 14 McGuill Residence 189 Center Street Historic Left elevation: Decking to be replaced with Boardwalk Landmark Collec- tion. FEB 0 5 2025 Cold King's Highway Historic District Project: McGuill Res dence Date. 1/17/2025, 7:19om Creator: Ed Stafford Front elevation: Decking to be replaced with Boardwalk Landmark Collec- tion. Project: McGuill Residence Date: 1/17/2025, 7:20am Creator: Ed Stafford 2 5 - A 0 2 3 :.,r.x Decking Replacement S j m McGuill Residence 189 Center Street Historic Front Door Replacement Front door to be replaced with a Simpson four lite door.(Side lights to be replaced to match existing) FEB 0 5 2025 Old King's Highway Historic: District �5-A023 rr°I! Front Door Replacement McGuill Residence 189 Center Street Historic 1 Simpson door specification to be used as new front door. Door to be painted white after. (Need color specification) Project! McGuill Residence Date: 1/17/2025, 7:14arn Creator: Ed Stafford tion showing main front door to be replaced. VOMP Q Le, It-W sill Residence 15, 7:19om tofford FEB 0 5 2025 Old King's Highway Historic District 2 5 - A 0 2 3 Front Door Replacement 6/ .a McGuill Residence FEB 0 5 2075 1,4 King'(-- inhwav Historic [ 7444 Thermal Sash Compare IP Compare 7482 7482 Thermal Sash Compare 2 5 - A 0 2 3 :'.' 189 Center Street Historic Barn Window Replacement Replace two windows on the front elevation of existing barn with windows to match existing home. FEB 0 5 2025 Old K ng's Highway Historic District 2 5 - A 0 2 3 Born Window Replocement 7/4& McGuill Residence 189 Center Street Historic Replace top gable window and lower window shown in photo with different window style to match existing home. Project: McGuill Residence Date: 1/17/2025, 7:12om Creator: Ed Stafford x FEB 0 5 Z025 s= id King's Highway Historic District cation for barn. �,5-A023 McGudi Resident Barn W,ndow Replacement Ns T iml "IP High -way 6c Distnct C.P . �44 77mill JL Jet On Lkh -r,= 189 Center Street Historic Main House Window Replacement Replace rotted windows on existing home. New windows to match existing grill patterns. FEB 0 5 2025 Old Kings Highway Historic District 2 5 - A 0 2 3 '' Main House Window Replacement 9: 'L McGuill Residence m m v o a � d v C d ro CO a, m z c w� c U 10 E too N N O yj fL d N E C J z W r U m � 04 0 � c No r E c a C� Z L H N P m M O N m m c4o C L6 m �cc r C � m m 'n N cn L x m r CO m rOlCm C e r a a z° C a 0.O E m a r- L) oa U 0t �; en N ^ _ J 0 O d +- m ��;ccrz N mO � O 'C Cam.. Iv CL N IN Ty C {Y1 OYf$ O O fnOa�J � ao Y =�'OG �O 7� I LU K �.02 C; OtfL O e' Ll 3 rn� -a m -0 C N r .2C=?i,�W^W 0 0 C la m m a TT 0-E f}-- Cl)pr ���- j .=IC = S- EZ.AaW pE Oz Ot�O x �` C .E.0 O V C .e0 m C r N c y O 0�r J 1= 5.0 II (L r !1 IcL •s MF 2.9 z -nOtc`tC0 W aC C zCO 7 mf LLSU�O-C8o2 Ecwp m 0� =% 0, E CO Q mo f 0 mE CZ �,Oli» JC41 dL Ae rna7� # o Y d N C O O 'C CL E E on �!s_ C U N FEB 0 5 2025 -,)Id King"s Highway Historic District a I X [�9 C �C 0 25-A023 ♦Y 189 Center Street Historic 1 ELL Window specifications to be replaced. Project: McGuill Residence Date: 1/17/2025, 7:12am Creator: Ed Stafford FEB 0 5 1015 Old King's Highway Historic District t exterior that are rotted to be re - la windows to match existing win- 25-A023 Main House Window Replacement 0 / 34 McGuill Residence 189 Center Street Historic Windows throughout exterior that are rotted to be re- placed with new Pella windows to match existing win- dows. Project: McGuill Residence Date: 1/17/2025, 7:20am Creator. Ed Stafford 'TID19NMR FEB 0 5 2025 Id King's Highway Historic District 2 5 - A 0 2 3 Main House Window Replacement 91 1 14 McGuill Residence 189 Center Street Historic - . ii!-. Exterior Trim, Roof Siding Repair & Color Change Full roof replacement, siding repair as needed, exterior trim replacement to match existing trim, whole home siding and trim to be painted hite. (Exact color specification needed). i (9t FEB 0 5 2025 Old Kings Highway Historic District 2 5 - A 023 Cxterior Trim, Roof Siding Repair & Color Change '7 { -d McGuill Residence 189 Center Street Historic All rotted trim to be replaced with white azek, screwed and plugged. All trim to match existing architectural style. at 13111111 UV;D FEB 0 5 2025 Old King's Highway Historic District Project; McGuill Residence Date: 1/17/2025, 7:19am Creator: Ed Stafford Existing roof to be stripped and replaced with asfault roofing. Project: McGuill Residence Date: 1/17/2025, 7:20om Creator: Ed Stafford 2 5 - A 0 2 3 Exterior Trim, Roof Siding Repair & Color Change 13114 McGuill Residence 189 Center Street Historic Paint exterior trim and siding white. Color-T• tb' Project: McGuill Residence Date: 1/17/2025, 7:20om Creator: Ed Stafford W FEB 0 5 2025 Old King's Highway Historic District 2 5 - A 0 2 3 Exterior Trim, Roof Siding Repair & Color Change X / `4 McGuill Residence �m N TZ I, _7 oop k 4A 't Ir IFWT 4k i 4k BULB high 78L-6.760 To: The Old Kings Highway Historic District Committee From: Cindy Ecker, Vice Chair Dl +r`• hAarN-h 7Q ' 025 tALV 1W. 4 L , 6VL3 Re: COA: 25-A023; Kelly McGuill and Lewis Bay Builders. I am not able to attend tonight's meeting due to a previously planned vacation, however, I would like to share my thoughts on this application. First of all, I wanted to thank Ms. McGuill for the opportunity to visit her home at 189 Center Street, Yarmouth Port. This house is a terrific example of Greek Revival architecture and one of the nicest houses in Yarmouth Port. Currently, the house exterior is composed of primarily orlainal elementss Busing the orjgina! materials Irn-t!.'S additions over time). j belie;ie thwt it is important to preserve this house with as much original material as possible. This is one of the tenets of The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Historic Rehabilitation, which OKH had previously adopted. Having said that, I strongly believe that 189 should retain as much of the original fabric as possible and replace same with like for like whenever possible. In reviewing the application submitted for tonight's meeting, it does not appear that it has changed from the original application submitted on February 25th. The application still states that they would like to remove and replace all roof, siding, exterior trim, deck boards, exterior doors, windows, deck posts and gutters. When we met at the property on March 7, 2025, the owner expressed her opinion that she would like to maintain as much of the historic details of the house that she could afford. We discussed the possibility of phasing the roof replacement, for example, so that the roof could be redone in red cedar, as currently exists. The roof on the front notion of the hoiY-so nnnanrcrri to be most in need of replacement, so that could be the candidate for this year. The builder agreed that this was possible. We also discussed the possibility of utilizing Fiberglass gutters or "duragutters" to be a closer replacement of the existing wooden gutters. And rather than wholesale replacement, I would like to see only the rotten sections being replaced, if possible. Furthermore, while onsite, the builder stated that they planned only to replace 4 windows that were not original and had failed. They also stated that they did NOT intend to replace any exterior doors, so hopefully, that is the case. The biggest issue that 1 have !'Vith this ap; tication is the cornplete removal Mnri dicrnnicat of the existing mahogany flooring decking and porches. They are in excellent condition with deterioration only at the front edge, not in need of full replacement. The application proposes to replace all decking with AZEK, which will also require that deck framing be either added to or replaced, since AZEK requires a closer nailing pattern than mahogany. While AZEK may be considered a GREEN budling product, the disposal of thousands or board feet of perfectly good mahogany and deck framing is a complete waste not a GREEN approach. 95% of the deck is in perfectly good condition. In fact, mahogany typically lasts for 100+ year, while AZEK has a lifespan of only 25 years. If the builder simply repaired the failing sections, including the supports fur the roo—F or1 the front cdthe ell, that would save the homeowner a tremendous amount of money that could potentially put toward a full red cedar roof! It is also important that the supports for the porch overhang line up with the brick foundation beneath. They are currently not supported. Thank you for your consideration. March 21, 2025 Sara Jane Porter 41 Ridgewood Drive Yarmouth Port MA 02675 Re: Yarmouth OKH Meeting 3/24/2025 To OKH Committee Members: I am sorry I am not able to attend the meeting tonight. New Item #1.25-A027 George Kennedy (Owner) and(fss is Bay Builder orever MA LLC (Agent): To install 41 solar panels on the iron and rear rot 395R 6A. I approve the installation of solar panels: • On the South facing dormer roof of the existing 1 '/ story front building • On the West side roof of the existing one story addition off the back of the front building because the visibility of these panels are negligible from Route 6A or Pine St. • On the roofs of the rear building at 395 Route 6A Re: The east facing roof of the existing one story addition off the back of the front building is more visible from 6A than the West facing roof of this structure. It would be ideal if the panels on this roof could be accommodated elsewhere. Assumed the designers have explored this option and because Governor Maura Healey's signed into law "Chaper 239 of the Acts of 2024 - Climate and Energy Siting Legislation requiring the Committee to give substantial weight to the threat posed by climate change and the Commonwealth's statewide obligation to meet greenhouse gas emission limits and sublimates established under Chapter 21 N when ruling on application of Certificates of Appropriateness for solar energy systems, I approve this application. Tabled Item #1. 25-A023 Kelly McGuill Owner and Lewis Bay Builders LLC (Agent): To replace roof, siding, trim, corner boards, doors, windows and deck posts and paint house at 189 Center Street. approve the following: Replace siding, trim, deck boards, doors, windows and deck posts as needed all of which will match existing profiles and styles unless otherwise stated. Repaint house once paint chips for house body, trim and door are submitted. Replace gutters once material and profile are submitted and approved by the other members of the committee. Re: the roof. Although the concept of a black roof with painted white sidewall shingles is an interesting and dynamic one, it is not appropriate, in my opinion, for this building in the OKH Historic District. I therefore do not approve the black asphalt roof shingles. Understanding that the expense of replacing red cedar wood shingles can be prohibitive, I agree that it is the preferred solution. Although this material is preferred, I would also approve Architectural Style Asphalt Shingles Weatherwood Color once sample is submitted with application. Sincerely, Sara Jane Porter